Content Writing Vs OpenAI: Who Does It Best?

For content writers, the words OpenAI can often send a chill down their spine. The thought of being replaced by a machine is the stuff of nightmares or horror movies. However, after a year or so of AI content writing services being around, the biggest question that comes to mind is “Who does it best”?

ContentCreativeSEOWeb

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Here at Sherbet Donkey, our content writers take huge pride in their work and are fully aware of how best to use OpenAI to their advantage.

    What is content writing?

    Content writing is simply the process of writing texts for websites to inform, persuade and influence readers to take certain actions. The main aim is to generate a response to the reading of the content, for instance, the purchasing of a product, service or signing up for a newsletter and more.

    Used in a variety of ways within marketing, content writing can be used for print ads, online marketing, websites and much more. When done effectively, content writing can inform, draw attention, create curiosity and even inspire readers to act in a certain way. In using the right words, persuasive techniques and an understanding of their target audience, content writers can adapt their writing to match the needs of their audience with maximum effect.

    What’s the difference between content writing and OpenAI?

    If you’re unsure of what OpenAI is, then where have you been for the last year? Taking the world by storm, OpenAI is a company that has developed artificial intelligence technology and is the creator of platforms such as ChatGPT, DALL-E, Bing and others that are capable of automatically creating text, pictures, code and more on given commands.

    When comparing the two, there are some quite significant differences. Essentially, content writing requires human skills and consists of writing persuasive and engaging texts, whilst focusing on understanding specific business objectives and consumer psychology. OpenAI primarily focuses on building algorithms and generating text based on patterns and data from the internet. However, OpenAI can be used as a fantastic tool for content writers, helping to research, find information to write content from and boost productivity.

    Are there benefits to content writing?

    There are many different benefits to using human-written content, in comparison to AI-generated copy. There is an emotional connection that is present when content is being written by content writers, human content incorporates emotion and empathy in the right places and instances, building a connection with readers. Content created by a person is also less repetitive and brings the human element of anecdotes and humour that AI cannot. Google will also rank human text more highly than AI-created content.

    In comparison to AI software, content created by a person is typically more original, unique and fresh. AI technologies find this incredibly difficult to recreate, making humanly written text much more obvious to spot due to its originality.

    The creativity of human written content shines clearly above that of OpenAI due to the use of popular references, jokes, puns and wordplay. All of which can keep readers engaged and build connections with the audience. Not only that, but the human mind can create versatile content for various formats, such as eBooks, social media posts, blogs and so much more.

    Disadvantages of content writing

    As with any content written by a human, there is always the concern of it being overly subjective and therefore more biased as writers can push their prejudices into their content. Investing in content writing can also be time-consuming and if outsourced in some instances can be quite costly as it requires effort and creativity. Scalability for human content can be difficult, as there is only so much content that can be produced before needing a break.

    Are there benefits to AI-generated content?

    Firstly, the most obvious benefit of AI software-generated content has to be how much time can be saved by using this technology. Content can be produced in a significant amount of time, by AI in comparison to content written by a person.

    Content created by OpenAI is based on algorithms and rules, so the content it produces will be consistent in quality. Not only that, AI-created text is easily scaled up in volume, due to its ability to produce content in a short amount of time, enabling businesses and individuals to create large quantities of content rapidly.

    Investing in a quality AI content tool such as OpenAI can be a relatively cost-effective option in comparison to human copywriters. The cost of resolving any errors is significantly lower for AI technologies than having errors caused by writing staff.

    Disadvantages of AI content

    However, there are some disadvantages to using AI content tools for your content creation. The lack of creativity has been a clear indication in deciding the difference between human and AI-generated content. As software like OpenAI uses algorithms and rules to create content, they are restricted when it comes to adding a creative touch to its content, it generally reads as repetitive and slightly robotic in style.

    There is usually a limited understanding of context. AI has not been programmed to understand the context of content like humans can, which can cause inappropriate or embarrassing content to be created. AI is also not always 100% factually correct –there is even a waiver at the bottom of the page to warn the user that they can make mistakes. Another issue with AI is dependence, if companies become over reliant on using AI to create content, it can significantly impact the quality of the content being produced and Google can rank the site lower than engagingly written human writing.

    So, who does it better? Content writers or AI software

    So, when it comes to content writing, who does it better? If you’re looking for quality content creation, there are benefits and disadvantages to both. The traditional form of content writing will always be more beneficial in most settings, however, using OpenAI as a tool to boost and benefit your content can positively impact the overall quality of your offerings without compromising on the emotions and humour that come with text written by a living, breathing person.

    If you’re struggling with your content and feel like you don’t know what to do to make it better, then we are here to help. Offering quality written content that is driven by SEO, our team of experienced writers can help take your company’s content to the next level.

    Hot takes and insights

    Get the inside scoop on SEO with our quick reads, from AI strategies to the latest Google core updates.

    Sherbet Donkey wins large SEO agency of the year at the UK Agency Awards 2026

    Q4 got off to a strong start when we brought back our biggest award to date: Large SEO Agency of the Year from the UK Agency Awards 2026! A few members of the team headed down to London for the awards and came back with two reasons to celebrate. Alongside the main win, we also


    Read more
    From invisible to visible: How an SEO audit transforms your website

    Whether your website is ranking well or your rankings look like s**t, an SEO audit is a practical way to see where you stand, what’s working, and what isn’t.


    Read more
    AI Overviews and SEO: how to get your content featured

    Search a question on Google today and there's a good chance the answer appears before you even reach the blue links. That's an AI Overview, and it's changed what SEO success actually looks like.


    Read more
    How to get your business mentioned in ChatGPT

    The way people search online is changing. Google may still have a vice-like grip on most searches for the time being, but it’s no longer the only place people go when they want to find a business, compare options or get a recommendation.


    Read more
    SEO audits explained: What proper agencies actually check

    As an agency that offers several SEO audit packages, we know it’s not a one-size-fits-all approach. An SEO audit checklist should be made around each business’s website and goals, with the results from the audit identifying issues followed by actionable recommendations that work in the business’s favour. Covering all aspects of SEO While SEO audits…


    Read more
    How to choose the right SEO audit for your business

    Key takeaways Not all SEO audits are equal; the right one depends on your business size, budget and the problem you’re actually trying to solve Sherbet Donkey offers four audit levels, from a free overview through to a full £3,149 enterprise review We prioritise every technical issue we find by critical/high, medium and low, so…


    Read more
    DIY SEO audit vs hiring an SEO agency

    The honest answer is that both have their place. If you’ve got a small website or you’re simply trying to understand the basics, doing your own audit can be a useful starting point. But if your website plays an important role in bringing in leads or sales, there’s a point where free tools and guesswork…


    Read more
    AEO vs GEO: What’s the Difference?

    Still confused? Don’t worry. This guide explains the difference between AEO and GEO, how they work alongside SEO and why your business should pay attention. What are Answer Engine Optimisation services? Answer Engine Optimisation (AEO) involves structuring content so search engines and AI tools can process it as a direct answer. It targets specific questions…


    Read more
    How AI-powered search is changing SEO (and how it isn’t)

    AI search isn’t just a far-off concept – it's already here. We cover everything you need to know about the future of SEO and intelligent, ‘agentic’ search in simple terms. No frills or frights required.


    Read more
    Your UX could be harming your SEO, and here’s why

    User experience (UX) and search engine optimisation (SEO) are deeply connected in the world of web design and hosting, but tend to be treated separately.


    Read more
    The new SERP: How AI Overviews are reshaping organic traffic

    You’ve likely typed a question into Google and found the answers right at the top of the page in an AI Overview. Google’s introduction of AI Overviews in 2024 has seen a dramatic shift in how we find information, which has led to websites reshaping their SEO (search engine optimisation) strategies.


    Read more
    Sherbet Donkey Celebrates Its 5th Anniversary

    This year, Sherbet Donkey turns five! It’s been half a decade since our director, Loki, tired of all-talk-and-no-results SEO services, took a leap and founded his own agency.


    Read more

    With over 100+ excellent reviews, why look anywhere else?